Artis, et al v. N.E. Compounding Pharmacy, Inc, et al

Artis, et al v. N.E. Compounding Pharmacy, Inc, et al
Lead case: v. New England Compounding Pharmacy, Inc. Products Liability Litigation

Court	First Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
Nature of Suit	Appeal - Torts

Case #	0:14-civil-01714
Filed	Jul 01, 2014

• Docket
• Parties

Last updated: Wed 07/02 6:41 AM EDT

Defendant HOWELL ALLEN CLINIC ,
Defendant DEBRA SCHAMBERG ,
Defendant INSIGHT IMAGING, INC. ,	Represented By Christopher E. Hassell Bonner, Kiernan, Trebach & Crociata, LLP contact info
Defendant SAINT THOMAS WEST HOSPITAL, f/k/a Saint Thomas Hospital ,	Represented By Michael E. Pikiel Jr. Fulbright & Jaworski LLP contact info Sarah P. Kelly Nutter McClennen & Fish LLP contact info
Defendant MEDICAL SALES MANAGEMENT SW, INC. ,	Represented By contact info
Defendant JOHN CULCLASURE ,
Defendant SAINT THOMAS NETWORK ,
Defendant SAINT THOMAS HEALTH ,
Defendant AMY VASSAR ,
Defendant ST THOMAS OUTPATIENT NEUROSURGICAL CENTER, LLC ,
Defendant - Appellee NEW ENGLAND COMPOUNDING PHARMACY, INC, d/b/a New England Compounding Center ,	Represented By Alan M. Winchester Harris Beach PLLC contact info Judi Abbott Curry Harris Beach PLLC contact info Jessica Saunders Eichel Harris Beach PLLC contact info Daniel E. Tranen Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP contact info Geoffrey M. Coan Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee AMERIDOSE, LLC ,	Represented By Richard Alan Dean Tucker Ellis LLP contact info Matthew Edward Mantalos Tucker Saltzman & Dyer LLP contact info Scott H. Kremer Tucker Saltzman & Dyer LLP contact info Scott J. Tucker Tucker Saltzman & Dyer LLP contact info Thomas Coffey contact info Paul Saltzman Tucker Saltzman & Dyer LLP contact info Matthew P. Moriarty Tucker Ellis LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee MEDICAL SALES MANAGEMENT, INC ,	Represented By Daniel M. Rabinovitz Michaels Ward & Rabinovitz LLP contact info Brady J. Hermann Michaels Ward & Rabinovitz LLP contact info Nicki Samson Michaels Ward & Rabinovitz LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee BARRY J. CADDEN ,	Represented By Robert H. Gaynor Sloane & Walsh LLP contact info John P. Ryan Sloane & Walsh LLP contact info William J. Dailey Jr. Sloane & Walsh LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee GREG CONIGLIARO ,
Defendant - Appellee LISA CONIGLIARO CADDEN ,
Defendant - Appellee GDC PROPERTIES MANAGEMENT, LLC ,	Represented By Joseph Paul Thomas Ulmer & Berne LLP contact info Robert Ambrose Curley Jr. Curley & Curley contact info Joshua A. Klarfeld Ulmer & Berne LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee ARL BIO PHARMA, INC ,	Represented By Kenneth B. Walton Donovan Hatem LLP contact info Kristen R. Ragosta Donovan Hatem LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee DOUGLAS CONIGLIARO ,	Represented By Christopher Reade O'Hara Todd & Weld LLP contact info Melinda L. Thompson Todd & Weld LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee CARLA CONIGLIARO ,
Defendant - Appellee GLENN CHIN ,
Defendant - Appellee SOUTH JERSEY HEALTHCARE ,	Represented By Michael B. Hayes Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP contact info Louis R. Moffa Jr. Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP contact info Kristen Muir Mykulak Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP contact info Stephen A. Grossman Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP contact info
Defendant - Appellee SOUTH JERSEY REGIONAL MEDICAL ,
Defendant - Appellee ALAUNUS PHARMACEUTICAL, LLC ,	Represented By Ryan A. Ciporkin Lawson & Weitzen LLP contact info Franklin H. Levy contact info
Defendant - Appellee NITESH BHAGAT ,	Represented By Joseph R. Lang Lenox Socey Formidoni Giordano Cooley Lang & Casey LLP contact info John M. Lovely Cashman & Lovely contact info
Defendant - Appellee CARRILION SURGERY CENTER NEW RIVER VALLEY, LLC, d/b/a New River Valley Surgery Center, LLC ,	Represented By Thomas Kincaid McCraw Jr. LeClair Ryan PC contact info Michael Preston Gardner Leclair Ryan PC contact info
Defendant - Appellee PREMIER ORTHOPAEDIC AND SPORTS MEDICINE ASSOCIATES OF SOUTHERN NJ, LLC, trading as Premier Orthopaedic Associates ,	Represented By Jay J. Blumberg Blumberg & Wolk LLC contact info Christopher M. Wolk Blumberg & Wolk LLC contact info
Defendant - Appellee PREMIER ORTHOPAEDIC ASSOCIATES SURGICAL CENTER, LLC ,
Defendant - Appellee KIMBERLY YVETTE SMITH, a/k/a Kimberly Yvette Smith-Martin, MD ,
Defendant - Appellee OCEAN STATE PAIN MANAGEMENT, INC ,	Represented By Sean E. Capplis Capplis & Connors PC contact info
Interested Party PAIN MEDICINE SPECIALISTS PA ,	Represented By Donald J. Walsh Offit Kurman, PA contact info
Interested Party UNIVERSAL PAIN MANAGEMENT MEDICAL CORPORATION, d/b/a/ Universal Pain Management ,	Represented By Paul Corson Law, Brandmeyer Packer, LLP contact info
Interested Party PAIN ASSOCIATES OF CHARLSETON, LLC, d/b/a InverveneMD ,	Represented By Robert Homes Hood Jr. Hood Law Firm contact info
Interested Party SAHARA OUTPATIENT SURGERY CENTER, LTD ,	Represented By Cari Wint Debevoise & Plimpton LLP contact info Mark P. Goodman Debevoise & Plimpton LLP contact info Maura K. Monaghan Debevoise & Plimpton LLP contact info
Interested Party HIGH POINT SURGERY CENTER ,	Represented By Terrill J. Harris Smith Moore Leatherwood LLP contact info Carrie A. Hanger Smith Moore Leatherwood LLP contact info
Interested Party INTERVENTIONAL SPINE & SPORTS MEDICINE, PC ,	Represented By Martin S. Hyman Golenbock, Eiseman, Assor & Bell contact info Matthew C. Daly Golenbock, Eiseman, Assor & Bell contact info
Interested Party HARFORD COUNTY AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTER, LLC ,	Represented By Thomas J. Althauser Eccelston and Wolf, PC contact info
Interested Party ENCINO OUTPATIENT SURGERY CENTER ,	Represented By Cynthia A. Palin Prindle, Amaro, Goetz, Hillyard, Barnes & Reinholtz contact info
Interested Party ALLEGHENY PAIN MANAGEMENT, PC ,	Represented By Allen P. Neely McQuaide, Blasko, Inc contact info
Interested Party DOYLESTOWN HOSPITAL ,	Represented By John B. Reiss Doylestown Hospital contact info
Interested Party ORLANDO CENTER FOR OUTPATIENT SURGERY, LP, d/b/a Orlando Center for Outpatient Surgery ,	Represented By Theresa A. Domenico McCumber Daniels Buntz Hartig & Puig PA contact info
Interested Party PAIN CONSULTANTS OF WEST FLORIDA ,	Represented By Halley M. Stephens Fuller, Mitchell, Hood & Stephens LLC contact info
Interested Party DR O'CONNELL'S PAIN CARE CENTER, INC ,	Represented By William E. Christie Shaheen & Gordon contact info
Interested Party ROCHESTER BRAIN AND SPINE NUEROSURGERY & PAIN MANAGEMENT, LLC ,	Represented By Alan J. Bozer Phillips Lytle LLP contact info Michael E. Hager contact info Joanna J. Chen Phillips Lytle LLP contact info
Interested Party GREENSPRING SURGICAL CENTER ,	Represented By John T. Sly Waranch & Brown LLC contact info
Interested Party INSIGHT HEALTH CORP ,	Represented By Clinton R. Shaw Bonner, Kiernan, Trebach & Crociata, LLP contact info Ron E. Meisler Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP contact info Brian J. Gerling Bonner, Kiernan, Trebach & Crociata, LLP contact info Matthew Joseph Matule Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP contact info
Interested Party NEUROMUSCULAR AND REHABILITATION ASSOCIATES OF NORTHERN MICHIGAN, and its employees ,	Represented By Timothy J. Dardas Hackney Grover Hoover & Bean PLC contact info Brett J. Bean Hackney Grover Hoover & Bean PLC contact info
Interested Party FORSYTH STREET AMBULATORY SURGERY CENTER, LLC ,	Represented By Jason D. Lewis Chambless Higdon Richardson Katz & Griggs contact info Emmittee H. Griggs Chambless Higdon Richardson Katz & Griggs contact info
Interested Party SURGERY CENTER OF WILSON, LLC ,	Represented By David H. Batten Batten Lee PLLC contact info G. Adam Moyers Batten Lee PLLC contact info C. Houston Foppiano Batten Lee PLLC contact info
Interested Party SOUTH BEND CLINIC, LLP ,	Represented By David E. Fialkow Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP contact info
Interested Party MARTIN KELVAS ,	Represented By Marcy Hogan Greer Alexander Dubose Jefferson & Townsend LLP contact info Yvonne K. Puig Fulbright & Jaworski contact info Eric J. Hoffman Fulbright & Jaworski contact info
Interested Party NORTH CAROLINA ORTHOPAEDIC CLINIC ,	Represented By Mark E. Anderson McGuire Woods LLP contact info
Interested Party BALTIMORE PAIN MANAGEMENT CENTER ,	Represented By Michelle J. Marzullo Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien, Doherty & Kelly, PC contact info
Interested Party SURGERY CENTER ASSOCIATES OF HIGHPOINT, LLC ,
Interested Party THOREK MEMORIAL HOSPITAL ,	Represented By Thomas J. Schlesinger Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith contact info Scott C. Bentivenga Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP contact info Kip Joseph Adams Lewis Brisbois Bisgard & Smith LLP contact info
Interested Party MICHIGAN PAIN SPECIALISTS, PLLC ,	Represented By Randy J. Hackney Hackney Grover Hoover & Bean PLC contact info C. Mark Hoover Hackney Grover Hoover & Bean PLC contact info
Interested Party HCA HEALTH SERVICES OF TENNESSEE, INC ,
Interested Party SURGICAL PARK CENTER, LTD ,
Interested Party SOUTHEAST MICHIGAN SURGICAL HOSPITAL ,	Represented By Kathryn J. Humphrey Dykema Gossett, PLLC contact info
Interested Party LIBERTY INDUSTRIES, INC ,	Represented By Nicole D. Dorman Rose Kallor, LLP contact info
Interested Party DR. DONALD JONES ,	Represented By John-Mark Zini Gideon Cooper & Essary PLC contact info Chris J. Tardio Gideon Cooper & Essary PLC contact info Matthew H. Cline Gideon Cooper & Essary PLC contact info C.J. Gideon Jr. Gideon Cooper & Essary PLC contact info
Interested Party SPECIALTY SURGERY CENTER, PLLC ,
Interested Party NEUROSURGICAL GROUP OF CHATTANOOGA, d/b/a Chattanooga Neurosurgery & Spine ,
Interested Party ERLANGER HEALTH SYSTEM ,	Represented By John B. Bennett Spears, Moore, Rebman & Williams, PC contact info Cara E. Weiner Spears, Moore, Rebman & Williams, PC contact info Arthur P. Brock Spears, Moore, Rebman & Williams, PC contact info
Interested Party J. DOES, 5-10 ,	Represented By Mark David Smith Laredo & Smith LLP contact info
Interested Party JOHN DOE, John Doe c/o Paul W. Shaw ,	Represented By Paul W. Shaw K&L Gates LLP contact info
Interested Party JOHN DOES. 1-4 ,	Represented By Michael J. Pineault Clements & Pineault LLP contact info
Interested Party LICHTENSTEINFISHWICK PLC, Roanoke Area Intervenors ,	Represented By Gregory Lee Lyons LichtensteinFishwick PLC contact info
Interested Party UNITED STATES ,	Represented By Zachary A. Cunha US Attorney's Office contact info
Interested Party VICTORY HEATING & AIR CONDITIONING CO., INC. ,	Represented By Michael P. Sams Kenney & Sams PC contact info
Interested Party CARLOS JASSIR, MD ,	Represented By Richard H. Ford Wicker, Smith, O'Hara, McCoy & Ford, PA contact info
Interested Party STATE OF TENNESSEE ,	Represented By Joseph Ahillen Office of Attorney General contact info Mary M. Bers Office of Attorney General contact info
Interested Party OSMC ,	Represented By Robert James Durant Jr. Edwards Wildman Palmer LLP contact info
Interested Party VICTORY MECHANICAL SERVICES, INC. ,
Interested Party GLADYS G. AUSTIN ,
Interested Party RICHARD BLAKENSHIP ,
Interested Party SHIRLEY DOYLE ,
Interested Party RENATE FARISS ,
Interested Party NANCY GOODFELLOW ,
Interested Party NORMA HURLEY ,
Interested Party MABEL HUTCHERSON ,
Interested Party ARNOLD MOON ,
Interested Party SHARON OVERSTREET ,
Interested Party MARY RADFORD ,
Interested Party NOSWORTHY REID ,
Interested Party CHERYL BROGAN ,
Interested Party CHRISTOPHER COMPTON ,
Interested Party TERRY DUNCAN ,
Interested Party DEBORAH HAGA ,
Interested Party LARRY HALL ,
Interested Party SUSANNE HASTINGS ,
Interested Party STUART KATZ ,
Interested Party JANE MCKEON ,
Interested Party ANGELA NORMAN ,
Interested Party JUDY RICE ,
Interested Party LARRY RICE ,
Interested Party DEANNA SMITH ,
Interested Party STEVIE THOMAS ,
Interested Party BRENDA VARLEY ,
Interested Party MIRIAM WARREN ,
Interested Party CHRISTINE WHEELER ,
Interested Party - Intervenor OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF UNSECURED CREDITORS, in the Chapter 11 Case of New England Compunding Pharmacy, Inc ,	Represented By David J. Molton Brown Rudnick LLP contact info Ann Andrews Andrews & Thornton contact info William R. Baldiga Brown Rudnick LLP contact info Rebecca L. Fordon Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Plaintiff KATHLEEN GUZMAN ,
Plaintiff - Appellant SANDRA F. ARTIS ,	Represented By James J. O'Keeffe IV Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info Benjamin D. Byrd Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info Jeffery Scott Sexton Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info Daniel R. Sullivan Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info Charles H. Smith III Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info Anthony M. Russell Gentry Locke Rakes & Moore LLP contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant DANA MARLENE BRADLEY ,
Plaintiff - Appellant RONNIE A. BROWN ,
Plaintiff - Appellant RONALD T. COURTNEY ,
Plaintiff - Appellant TRUDY R. EPPERLY ,
Plaintiff - Appellant BARBARA J. FILSON ,
Plaintiff - Appellant Z.L.F., a minor, by his parents and next friends, Benjamin T. Foutz and Andrea L. Foutz ,
Plaintiff - Appellant ROBERT EARL HARRIS, JR. ,
Plaintiff - Appellant JULIAN D. HOLBROOK ,
Plaintiff - Appellant ROBERT DANA BENDER, Executor of the Estate of Ralph James Irace, Jr., Deceased ,
Plaintiff - Appellant CHESTER T. KALINOSKI ,
Plaintiff - Appellant PAULINE R. MCFARLANE ,
Plaintiff - Appellant ODESSA M. SHUCK ,
Plaintiff - Appellant JAMES WIRT SMITH, JR. ,
Plaintiff - Appellant RANDOLPH E. SMITH ,
Plaintiff - Appellant PATRICIA S. BROWN, Executor of the Estate of Louis B. Spicer, Deceased ,
Plaintiff - Appellant JOHN D. SPICER, Executor of the Estate of Louis B. Spicer, Deceased ,
Plaintiff - Appellant JENAE S. PATSELL, Executor of the Estate of Louis B. Spicer, Deceased ,
Plaintiff - Appellant ROSE M. WHITE ,
Plaintiff - Appellant RICHARD A. WHITLOW ,
Plaintiff - Appellant SHARON G. WINGATE, Executor of the Estate of Douglas Gray Wingate, Deceased ,
Trustee PAUL D. MOORE, in his capacity as Chapter 11 Trustee of the Defendant New England Compounding Pharmacy, Inc. d/b/a New England Compounding Center ,	Represented By Thomas B.K. Ringe III Duane Morris LLP contact info Michael Ross Gottfried Duane Morris LLP contact info Jennifer Mikels Duane Morris LLP contact info

last updated: Wed 07/02 6:41 AM EDT
Tuesday, July 01, 2014
	CIVIL CASE docketed. Notice of appeal (doc. #1232) filed by Appellants Sandra F. Artis, Robert Dana Bender, Dana Marlene Bradley, Patricia S. Brown, Ronnie A. Brown, Ronald T. Courtney, Trudy R. Epperly, Barbara J. Filson, Robert Earl Harris, Jr., Julian D. Holbrook, Chester T. Kalinoski, Pauline R. McFarlane, Jenae S. Patsell, Odessa M. Shuck, James Wirt Smith, Jr., Randolph E. Smith, John D. Spicer, Rose M. White, Richard A. Whitlow, Sharon G. Wingate and Z.L.F.. Docketing Statement due 07/15/2014. Transcript Report/Order form due 07/15/2014. Appearance form due 07/15/2014. 14-1714 (CP) Related: [-]
	NOTICE requesting removal from the service list filed by Attorney Thomas Kincaid McCraw, Jr. for Appellee Carrilion Surgery Center New River Valley, LLC in 13-2007 Attorney Thomas Kincaid McCraw, Jr. for Respondent Carrilion Surgery Center New River Valley, LLC in 14-1718 14-1714 Certificate of service dated 07/01/2014. 13-2007 14-1714 14-1718 (TKM)